Draft policy on new fisheries open for comment as coastal roadshow gets under way
Stakeholders have until 27 November to comment on new policy
SOUTH AFRICA: Stakeholders have until midnight on 27 November to comment on a draft policy that will determine how new wild marine fisheries are opened up in South Africa, and how existing regulated fisheries may expand into new areas or adopt new fishing methods.
The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) is holding a series of public consultations along the coast on the draft. However, the opening session in Cape Town, the only one to offer a virtual option, took place before the roadshow schedule was sent to the media.
The Draft Policy for the Development of New Wild Marine Fisheries and the Expansion of Regulated Wild Marine Fisheries in South Africa: 2026 was published for comment by the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, David Maynier, on 23 October in terms of the Marine Living Resources Act (MLRA). It sets out how applications will be handled for exploratory fishing, the geographic expansion of existing fisheries, trials of new fishing methods and the collection of samples for research and product development.
The roadshow was not extensively advertised on the department's media channels, and the schedule was only distributed to the media on Sunday 8 November after the consultations had started. As a result, Cape Town, a major fishing centre and home to many of the commercial right holders, processors, researchers and industry bodies directly affected by the policy, had its only session before many stakeholders would have known about it.
A roadshow with little notice
The hybrid session at the Foretrust Building in Cape Town on 6 November was the first stop on the roadshow. The remaining 29 meetings, which run until 20 November, are in-person only and are held in coastal towns from Port Nolloth on the West Coast to St Lucia in KwaZulu-Natal.
The roadshow was not extensively advertised on the department's media channels, and the schedule was only distributed to the media on Sunday 8 November after the consultations had started. As a result, Cape Town, a major fishing centre and home to many of the commercial right holders, processors, researchers and industry bodies directly affected by the policy, had its only session before many stakeholders would have known about it.
With the virtual option now gone, stakeholders who are not near one of the remaining venues, including inland investors, technology developers and researchers, have no further opportunity to take part in the consultations.
The industry has repeatedly called for improved stakeholder engagement opportunities, and to give stakeholders adequate notice so that they can participate meaningfully in decisions that affect their businesses and livelihoods.
The remaining sessions are as follows, with most running from 10:00 to 13:00:
◼︎ West Coast: Port Nolloth (9 November), Hondeklip Bay (10 November), Doring Bay and Lamberts Bay (11 November), Elands Bay and St Helena Bay (12 November), Saldanha Bay (13 November), Yzerfontein (17 November), Hermanus (18 November), Gansbaai (19 November) and Kleinmond (20 November).
◼︎ South Coast: Bredasdorp (10 November), Still Bay (11 November), Mossel Bay (12 November), Plettenberg Bay (13 November), Cape St Francis and Humansdorp (16 November), Gqeberha (17 November), Port Alfred (18 November) and Hamburg (19 November).
◼︎ KwaZulu-Natal: St Lucia (9 November), Richards Bay (10 November), Durban (11 November) and Gamalakhe near Port Shepstone (12 November).
◼︎ Eastern Cape: Mzamba (13 November), Port St Johns (16 November), Coffee Bay (17 November), Kei Mouth (18 November) and East London (19 November).
Key issues in the draft
Although the draft lists equity and the inclusion of historically disadvantaged participants among its objectives, the criteria used to assess applications for exploratory fishing cover only fishing experience, access to a vessel and gear. Nothing in the criteria scores ownership, small-scale or cooperative participation, or the inclusion of women and youth. The criteria are described as weighted, but the weightings are not disclosed.
The requirements for applicants are also likely to favour established, well-resourced operators. Before any permit is issued, applicants must show more than five years' fishing experience, proof of access to a vessel and proof that they already own the necessary gear.
They must also submit a desktop literature study and a detailed two-year operational plan. This sits uneasily with the policy's own equity aims and with the interests of the small-scale sector.
Only existing right, permit or exemption holders in a fishery may trial new gear or technology. Gear developers, technology companies, researchers and new entrants are excluded unless they partner with a right holder.
Existing right holders should also take note. The draft allows total allowable catch (TAC) or total allowable effort (TAE) to be apportioned from a regulated fishery for exploration, but it does not say how much may be apportioned; whether current right holders will be consulted, or whether they will be compensated.
For potential investors, the draft offers limited certainty. Permits are issued annually; projects terminate automatically, and completing the exploratory phase guarantees nothing. When an exploratory fishery is declared a new fishery, rights are allocated through the ordinary allocation process, and preference "may" be given to past participation and investment.
There is no protection for a proponent who initiates a fishery and pays for the desktop study, as others may apply on the strength of that work. Applicants also carry the costs of observers, electronic monitoring and research through approved institutions, and the draft does not say whether exploratory catch may be sold commercially.
Other concerns include:
◼︎ The New Fisheries Scientific Working Group, which receives applications and decides on project durations, is not defined in terms of its composition, mandate or management of conflicts of interest.
◼︎ Applicants are excluded if any member, shareholder or director has a conviction under the MLRA, with no time limit. This would be difficult to apply to widely held companies and cooperatives.
◼︎ The department will be the custodian of all submitted data, including commercially sensitive economic and market information, with no provision for confidentiality or intellectual property in new gear or methods.
◼︎ The sample collection route requires a vessel, gear, a two-year operational plan and fishing experience, which is ill-suited to researchers.
The draft is also silent on several matters, including whether exploration may take place in marine protected areas; how it relates to marine spatial planning, overlap with offshore oil, gas, mining and shipping; shared stocks managed by regional fisheries bodies; the recreational sector; a dedicated pathway for small-scale fishers, and transitional arrangements for experimental fisheries that are already operating.
In addition, foreign vessels may be used where local capacity is not available, but the draft does not set out how this will be tested.
How to comment
Written comments must reach the department by midnight on 27 November. Submissions can be emailed to NFPolicy@dffe.gov.za. The Gazette notice also lists MRothman@dffe.gov.za and QMketsu@dffe.gov.za, and stakeholders may wish to copy all three addresses. Submissions should refer to Government Notice 8084 in Government Gazette 55620.
Comments will be published with the name of the person or organisation that submitted them. Anyone who objects to this must state so in bold in their submission. Submissions carry more weight when they refer to specific paragraph numbers in the draft and propose alternative wording.
Enquiries can be directed to Mark Rothman on 083 564 3440 or MRothman@dffe.gov.za.
391